Caswell Beach
Three square miles at the quiet end of Oak Island, one road in and out, a lighthouse the town owns, and a flood zone on almost every lot.
Neighborhood Overview: Caswell Beach homes for sale
Caswell Beach is the quiet end of Oak Island, and it is its own town. The Census Bureau’s TIGERweb boundary file, queried November 11, 2026, gives it 3.07 square miles of land on the east tip of the island, in Brunswick County, ZIP 28465. The 2020 Census counted 395 residents in 681 housing units, and the 2020-2024 American Community Survey puts the population at 491.
Read those together and you have the town. On that survey, 447 of 675 units were vacant on census day, 272 held for seasonal or occasional use and 167 listed for rent. Only 228 were occupied. Two thirds of Caswell Beach is a second home or a rental, and that drives the insurance, the winter quiet and the resale pool.
The shape is simple. Caswell Beach Road runs the length of it, ocean on one side, salt marsh and the Intracoastal Waterway on the other. At the east end it stops at Fort Caswell, where the Baptist State Convention of North Carolina has run a conference center since 1949, beside an active Coast Guard station. Head west and the town line hands you to Oak Island. There is no other way in or out.
There is also no commercial strip. No grocery, no shops, no restaurants, and the town’s own golf cart page tells residents they drive to the stores on Oak Island. What it has instead is a lighthouse it owns outright, a golf course, a conservation-zoned maritime forest and a beach that rarely feels busy. The survey puts the median year built at 1998 and the median home value at $648,400 against $349,800 countywide.
Home Price Ranges
Coldwell Banker runs a public search for Caswell Beach, NC, and we read it on November 11, 2026. It held 20 records, 18 active and 2 pending. We ran all 13 of its map coordinates through the Census Bureau’s geocoder first, and every one came back inside the town limits. That matters, because Caswell Beach shares ZIP 28465 with Oak Island and plenty of searches blur the two.
The 18 actives ran $395,000 to $2,300,000, median $677,500, median 90 days on market. Call it three markets. Seven condominiums, every one at 1000 Caswell Beach Road, ran $395,000 to $569,000 in roughly 720 to 1,010 square feet. Two townhouses by the golf course listed at $695,000 and $729,000, and six single family homes ran $655,000 to $2,300,000, median $1,247,500.
Two numbers tell you the rest. None of the 20 records was new construction, because the town is built out. And the listings sit: several actives had been on more than 290 days, one of them 597, against a countywide median of 93 days in the three months ending September 2026. See our Brunswick County market update, and our Oak Island, Southport, Bald Head Island and St. James Plantation guides for the alternatives.
Lifestyle & Community
Everything below is inside the town limits, and short by design:
- Oak Island Lighthouse, Caswell Beach Road. The town owns it, deeded over in 2004 under the federal Land to Parks program, and the volunteer Friends of Oak Island Lighthouse run the tours. The climb is 131 steps up ships ladders, and the color was mixed into the concrete, so it has never needed paint.
- North Carolina Baptist Assembly at Fort Caswell, at the east end of the road. A Baptist State Convention ministry hosting retreats on the old fort grounds since 1949, with grounds tours by pass if you call ahead.
- Oak Island Golf Club, 928 Caswell Beach Road. The island’s golf course sits in Caswell Beach, not Oak Island, with fairways threading through the Caswell Dunes homes.
- Caswell Beach Maritime Forest, a 10-acre stand the NC Wildlife Resources Commission would rather nobody touched, protected under town Ordinance 98.01 in 2018.
- Two public beach accesses, one with restrooms and one at the lighthouse, plus a beach wheelchair the town lends out. Dogs run off leash under voice control dawn to 9 am, and all day from mid-October to mid-March.
For dinner out, groceries or a marina you are driving: Oak Island about 12 minutes west, Southport about 13 north.
Schools & Education
Six Caswell Beach addresses run through Brunswick County Schools’ Edulog lookup on November 11, 2026 returned the same three schools:
- Southport Elementary, grades K-5, about 8 miles by road. On NC DPI’s 2025-26 results, 65.1 percent of students tested at grade level and it met growth at 1.18.
- South Brunswick Middle, grades 6-8. This is the weak link and we will not soften it: 52.1 percent at grade level, growth not met at -4.95, a School Performance Grade of D, and a place on the state’s 2025-26 low-performing designations. It is one of only two Brunswick County schools on that list.
- South Brunswick High, grades 9-12. 63.8 percent at grade level and exceeded growth at 2.20.
The district came in at 59.9 percent, the state 59.2. Run the exact address before you write an offer.
Getting Around
Caswell Beach Road is the only road in and the only road out. No bridge, no second exit, no back way, which matters most in hurricane season. Distances below are approximate, from Town Hall, by OpenStreetMap routing with no traffic on November 11, 2026. The beach is not on the list because it is across the road.
- Fort Caswell about 3.3 miles, 8 minutes
- Oak Island town center about 4.8 miles, 12 minutes
- Southport about 6.7 miles, 13 minutes
- Downtown Wilmington about 30.7 miles, 47 minutes
- Wilmington International Airport about 34.3 miles, 56 minutes
- Wrightsville Beach about 39.4 miles, 62 minutes
Golf carts are common and the rules are stricter than people expect. Carts not registered as street legal may not be driven on Caswell Beach Road, and any cart on a public access way needs a Town Hall permit on it.
What Buyers Should Know
Almost every lot here is in a flood zone. We queried the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer at all 13 listing locations on November 11, 2026. Ten sat in the Special Flood Hazard Area: nine in Zone AE at a base flood elevation of 10 feet NAVD88, one in Zone VE, the coastal high hazard band, at 14 feet. The other three came back Zone X in the 0.2 percent band. None returned minimal flood hazard. The map is FIRM panel 3720208500K, effective August 28, 2018. A VE designation changes how a house must be built and what it costs to insure, so pull the determination on the parcel.
Insurance works differently here because most of the town is not owner-occupied. Dwelling policies, which cover residences of up to four units that are not the owner’s primary home, are what much of Caswell Beach runs on. The NC Rate Bureau filed on October 30, 2025 for a statewide 68.3 percent increase. Commissioner Causey settled it on April 22, 2026 at an average 5 percent a year, effective October 1, 2026 and 2027, with mitigation credits for fortified roofs. Read the wind and hail deductible, not just the premium.
You pay two property tax rates. Brunswick County charges 0.3420 per $100 for Fiscal Year 2025 and Caswell Beach adds 0.19, unchanged across the 2024, 2025 and 2026 columns. Combined that is 0.5320. On a $655,000 house, the median residential asking price in town, the bill is roughly $3,485 a year, $1,245 of it the town line.
The sand is managed. The town has a US Army Corps of Engineers dredging project from 2024-25 and a FY26 Wilmington Harbor Inner Ocean Bar contract placing sand on the strand, plus a beach management plan from Coastal Protection Engineering and a flood program under FEMA’s Community Rating System. A town builds that because the shoreline moves. Ask what the profile in front of a specific house has done.
Utilities are county, the association is not. Brunswick County Public Utilities supplies water and sewer, so no wells and no septic. Caswell Beach Plantation alone is four separate property owner associations, so get the covenants and dues for the right one.
If you plan to rent it out, confirm the rules first. The survey shows 167 units listed for rent, so rentals are part of the fabric. We could not read the town’s current rental provisions the day we built this guide. Call Town Hall at 910-278-5471 and get it in writing before you underwrite rental income.