Yes, and the decision is yours to make, not your agent’s and not your buyer’s. Whether you should is a different question, and in North Carolina there is a real reason to consider it: during the due diligence period your buyer can walk away for any reason at all, and you would be back on the market having lost two or three weeks.
Sellers ask this in two very different moods. Some are nervous about their buyer and want a safety net. Others got a call from an agent who wants to show the house on Saturday and feel uneasy about saying yes while a contract is signed. Both instincts are reasonable, and the answer turns on how our standard contract actually works.
Why this is even a question in North Carolina
In our contract, “under contract” is a softer commitment than buyers arriving from other states expect. Paragraph 4(g) of the Offer to Purchase and Contract, Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025, gives the buyer the right to terminate “for any reason or no reason” by delivering written notice during the due diligence period, with time of the essence. No inspection finding is required. No explanation is owed to you.
Your compensation for that risk is the due diligence fee, which under paragraph 1(l) becomes the seller’s property on the effective date and is non-refundable except in the case of a material breach by the seller or termination under paragraph 23(b). On most Wilmington-area sales that fee is a fraction of what two or three weeks off the market costs you, which is exactly why a seller with a shaky buyer thinks about keeping the door open.
The market context matters here too. With the typical New Hanover County home taking 61 days to go under contract against 34 a year ago, and about two in five active listings already carrying a price cut, a listing that falls out of contract and returns to the market is not stepping back into a scramble of buyers (Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update, October 2026). Losing your place in line costs more this fall than it did last fall.
What showing after contract actually buys you
The thing a second buyer can give you is a back-up contract, and North Carolina has a form for exactly that: the Back-Up Contract Addendum, Standard Form 2A1-T, revised 7/2025. It is worth understanding what it does and does not promise.
Under paragraph 7, when the primary contract is terminated you must promptly give the back-up buyer written notice that their contract has become primary plus written evidence the primary contract ended, which together the form calls Notice of Primary Status. Under paragraph 6, if the primary contract closes, the back-up contract is null and void and the back-up buyer’s earnest money is refunded. Under paragraph 10 the parties fill in a date and time by which the back-up buyer must receive Notice of Primary Status, after which the back-up contract is void.
Now the limitation. Paragraph 9 lets the back-up buyer terminate without liability, with their earnest money refunded, at any time before they receive Notice of Primary Status. So a back-up contract is not a sale waiting in the wings. It is a signed first option that the other party can abandon at will, which is still considerably better than an empty calendar.
The limits your agent has to respect
Saying yes to showings does not make everything fair game, and the constraints are mostly about how competing buyers are treated.
The North Carolina Real Estate Commission expects brokers to treat prospective buyers equally in a multiple offer situation. The practical rule is that if a listing agent discloses the existence of competing offers to one buyer, that fact must be disclosed to all the competing buyers, not just the one who asked. At the same time, nothing in our license law requires a listing agent to volunteer information about other offers, and a listing agent’s duty is to get you the best bargain available under the circumstances.
NC REALTORS has also cautioned brokers against giving a losing buyer’s agent the details of other offers while a contract is in place, because it can be viewed as shopping for back-up terms the seller might accept if the primary deal collapses. And a listing agent’s duty to disclose material facts about the property does not switch off when the home goes under contract, which includes disclosing them to a back-up buyer.
One more piece of the puzzle, from the back-up form itself: under paragraph 5 of Form 2A1-T, the back-up buyer may not examine or otherwise have access to the primary contract without written permission from both you and the primary buyer. Your deal’s terms stay yours.
What we usually suggest, and when we do not
For most of our listings, we take the showing sign down once due diligence is behind us and the appraisal has cleared, and we keep taking back-up offers on paper for the rest of the way. That gives you protection where the risk actually lives, in the first three weeks, without asking your family to keep the house showing-ready for 45 days.
We argue for keeping showings running during due diligence when the file has a specific weak spot: no real lender letter, a buyer whose purchase depends on selling another home, an unusually long due diligence period, or a price at the very top of what the comps will support. In those cases the cost of staying showing-ready is cheap insurance.
We argue against it when the buyer is strong and the household cannot absorb it. A seller with small children, a dog and a job does not need three more weeks of Saturday showings to protect against a risk that is already small. Our listing services page explains how we handle the showing calendar either way, and if you are still deciding how to price the listing in the first place, the county-level picture is on our New Hanover County market update.
The honest downside is relational, not legal. A primary buyer who learns the house is still being shown often reads it as a signal you expect them to fail, and buyers who feel that way get less generous in repair negotiations. The existence of a back-up contract is generally not treated as a material fact you must disclose to your primary buyer, and nothing prohibits telling them either, so it becomes a judgment call you should make deliberately with your agent rather than by accident. Two practical limits as well: if the home is tenant-occupied, showings depend on the tenant’s cooperation and the lease, not on your preference; and what your agent must change in the MLS when the home goes under contract is governed by local MLS rules that we are not going to summarize from memory here, so ask your agent to show you the current rule before you assume the listing can keep appearing as it did last week.
Related questions people also ask
Do I have to tell my buyer that I am accepting back-up offers?
Generally no. The existence of a back-up contract is not usually treated as a material fact about the property that must be disclosed to the buyer already under contract, and there is also nothing prohibiting you from telling them. That makes it a strategy decision rather than a legal one, and the right answer depends on your read of the buyer. Some buyers tighten up and move faster when they know someone is behind them, and others get defensive, so talk it through with your agent before anyone volunteers it.
Can a back-up buyer see the terms of my primary contract?
Not without permission. Under paragraph 5 of the Back-Up Contract Addendum, Standard Form 2A1-T, revised 7/2025, the back-up buyer may not examine or otherwise have access to the primary contract without written permission from both the seller and the primary buyer. The form does ask the seller to state the settlement date called for in the primary contract, so the back-up buyer learns the timeline but not the price or terms. If you are the seller, do not let anyone share the contract itself without your written consent.
If my buyer terminates during due diligence, do I keep the due diligence fee?
Yes, in almost every case. Under paragraph 1(l) of Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025, the due diligence fee becomes the property of the seller on the effective date and is non-refundable, with narrow exceptions for a material breach by the seller or a termination under paragraph 23(b) or as provided in an addendum. The earnest money deposit is treated differently and is refunded to the buyer when they terminate properly within the due diligence period. So a terminated contract usually leaves you with the fee, the lost time, and a listing that needs to go back on the market.
Before your next showing request, decide three things with your agent in writing: whether showings continue through due diligence, whether you will accept back-up offers on Form 2A1-T, and what your agent may and may not say to a competing buyer’s agent. If you want help reading how strong your buyer actually is before you make that call, send our team the contract and the lender letter and we will tell you where the risk is.
Sources: North Carolina Offer to Purchase and Contract, Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025, paragraphs 1(l), 4(g) and 23(b). Back-Up Contract Addendum, Standard Form 2A1-T, revised 7/2025, paragraphs 5, 6, 7, 9 and 10. North Carolina Real Estate Commission guidance on equal treatment of competing buyers and NC REALTORS legal Q&A on disclosing competing and back-up offers. Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update, October 2026 (61 days on market against 34 a year ago; about two in five active listings with a price cut).



