Usually yes on a conventional loan, but the rules changed on September 2, 2026 and the lease you were planning to show no longer counts. Fannie Mae now requires market rent to come from an appraisal, a Form 1007 rent schedule or a market analysis with at least three comparable rentals, and only 75 percent of that rent can be used.
This is the question we get from almost every move-up buyer in Wilmington who does not want to sell first. You have a house you like the payment on, you want a bigger one, and you would rather keep the old one and rent it out than hand it to a buyer at this fall’s prices. Whether that works comes down to one calculation your lender runs, and it is worth understanding before you fall in love with a second house.
The short version of the math: your lender takes 75 percent of the market rent, subtracts the full payment on the house you are leaving, and whatever is left over either disappears or lands in your debt-to-income ratio as a monthly obligation. It never becomes extra income you can spend on the new house.
What changed in September 2026
Fannie Mae reorganized its rental income rules in Announcement SEL-2026-08 and moved departing residences into their own section, B3-3.8-05. The change that matters most to buyers here is a document that used to be routine and is now prohibited.
- Lease agreements are not permitted for any departing residence Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-05, dated September 2, 2026, read November 8, 2026
- Market rent must come from a full appraisal that includes market rents, a Form 1007 Single-Family Comparable Rent Schedule, or a market analysis tool showing at least three comparable rentals Same section, November 8, 2026
- 75 percent of monthly gross rent is counted as net rental income Same section, November 8, 2026
- If the borrower has less than 12 months of property management experience, the lender must verify six months of reserves covering the vacated property’s full payment Same section, November 8, 2026
Read that first line twice if you have already signed a tenant. We have had two buyers this fall who lined up a renter for the house they were leaving, assumed the signed lease was the proof the lender wanted, and found out at underwriting that it bought them nothing. The lease still matters for the tenant relationship. It just is not the document that gets you approved.
How the 75 percent math actually works
The 25 percent that comes off the top is a vacancy and maintenance factor. It is not negotiable, and it is not a judgment about your house.
What the lender does next is the part people get wrong. It subtracts the departing home’s full PITIA, meaning principal, interest, taxes, insurance and any association dues, from that 75 percent figure. Fannie Mae calls the result adjusted monthly net rental income. If the result is positive, it is allowed to cancel out the departing home’s payment and nothing more. If the result is negative, the shortfall goes into your debt-to-income ratio as a monthly debt against the new loan.
So the best case is that the old house stops counting against you. There is no case where it helps you buy more house.
What that looks like with real Wilmington rents
Put county numbers on it. The Census Bureau’s most recent one-year estimates put median gross rent at $1,607 in New Hanover County, $1,449 in Pender and $1,329 in Brunswick. For three-bedroom units, the kind of house most move-up sellers are leaving behind, New Hanover comes in at $1,875.
- Median gross rent, New Hanover County: $1,607, margin of error $70. Three-bedroom units: $1,875, margin of error $138 American Community Survey 2024 one-year estimates, tables B25064 and B25031, read November 8, 2026
- Median gross rent, Pender County $1,449 and Brunswick County $1,329 Same tables, November 8, 2026
- 75 percent of a $1,875 market rent is $1,406 of countable net rental income Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-05; arithmetic ours
- This week’s 30-year fixed average: 7.18 percent, down from 7.40 percent four weeks earlier Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week ending November 5, 2026
- Principal and interest on a $464,000 New Hanover County median-priced home with 20 percent down at 7.18 percent: about $2,515 a month Freddie Mac PMMS week ending November 5, 2026, and our New Hanover County market update, three months ending September 2026; arithmetic ours
Now run two households through it, treating the payments as illustrations rather than as market data. A seller whose departing house carries a $1,150 monthly payment, which in this market usually means a loan taken out before 2022, lands at positive $256 after the subtraction. That cancels the old payment and the lender moves on. The new purchase gets qualified as though the old house did not exist.
A seller whose departing house carries a $2,400 monthly payment lands at negative $994, and that $994 becomes a monthly debt in the ratio. On most incomes it takes a meaningful bite out of what the new house can be. For scale on how easily a payment reaches that level here, principal and interest alone on a house at the $464,000 New Hanover County median, with 20 percent down at this week’s 7.18 percent, runs about $2,515 a month before taxes, insurance or association dues.
The dividing line, in other words, is not whether your old house will rent. It is whether it will rent for more than about 133 percent of its own payment. In most of New Hanover County right now, a house bought in the last three years will not. A house bought in 2019 often will. Our mortgage update has the current rate and the payment math behind those figures.
FHA and VA play by different rules
If you are using an FHA or VA loan, do not assume the conventional answer transfers. Both programs attach their own conditions to counting rent from a house you are vacating, and FHA’s are materially tighter than Fannie Mae’s, including tests around how far you are moving and how much equity you hold.
We are not going to put a number on those tests here, because the versions circulating on lender blogs disagree with each other and we could not pull the current handbook language today. What we tell our buyers is simpler and more useful: make the loan officer show you the handbook section in writing, with the date, before you write an offer on the strength of rent you have not collected yet. Any lender worth using will do that in an email inside an hour.
Two honest caveats. First, the Census rent figures above are gross rent, which includes utilities the tenant pays, so a landlord collects less than those numbers suggest. They are useful for sizing up a market, not for predicting your check. Second, and bigger: qualifying is only one question. Being a landlord is another. You will hold the roof, the HVAC and the vacancy risk on a coastal house while you are also carrying a new mortgage, and a single storm-season insurance increase can move your math after the loan closes. For some of our clients the right answer is still to sell, take the equity and buy clean. We would rather you reach that conclusion before the appraisal than after.
Related questions people also ask
Does the rent have to be collected before I can use it?
No. For a departing residence the lender is looking at supportable market rent rather than rent you have already banked, which is why the documentation now comes from an appraiser or a comparable-rent analysis rather than from a lease. What the lender does want to see is a documented current housing payment on that property. If you have genuinely been a landlord for a year or more, that experience can also remove a reserve requirement.
Can I use rental income from a house I have owned and rented for years?
Yes, and that case is treated differently from a departing residence. Established rental property income is normally documented with tax returns showing the rent on Schedule E, which is a stronger and simpler path than the market rent analysis a departing home requires. If you are in that position, bring two years of returns to the lender conversation and ask them to qualify you on the Schedule E figures.
Will keeping my old house hurt my chances of winning an offer?
It can, because the listing agent on the other side is reading your approval letter for signs of fragility, and a file that depends on rent is one more thing to question. The fix is preparation rather than secrecy. Have the rent analysis and the reserves documented before you tour, so your lender can write an approval letter that does not carry a condition about the other house. A clean letter is worth real negotiating room in a market where sellers are already waiting longer than they expected.
Before you shop, ask your lender for a written pre-approval run both ways, once with the departing house rented and once with it sitting empty, so you can see exactly what the rent is worth to your price range. If you are weighing keeping it against selling it, our posts on buying before you sell and renting out instead of selling work through the other side of the decision. When you want someone to run your actual numbers, schedule a consultation and we will sit down with them.
Sources: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-05, Rental Income from Non-Subject Property: Departing Residence, dated September 2, 2026, and Announcement SEL-2026-08, read November 8, 2026. American Community Survey 2024 one-year estimates, tables B25064 and B25031, read November 8, 2026. Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week ending November 5, 2026. Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update, three months ending September 2026.



