Do I Have to Disclose a Prior Insurance Claim in NC?

There is no general insurance-claim question on the NC form, but there is a flood-claim question. Your buyer's insurer sees the history anyway.
Roofer installing asphalt shingles on a residential roof
The short answer

There is no question on the North Carolina disclosure form about insurance claims in general, but since July 2024 there is one about flood claims, and you have to answer it. The bigger point for a coastal seller is that the buyer’s insurer will see the property’s claims history anyway, so hiding one rarely survives contact with the underwriting.

We get this question most from owners in Carolina Beach, Oak Island and the older parts of Wilmington who filed a wind or water claim after a storm, had the work done properly, and now worry that disclosing it will scare a buyer off. It is a fair worry. It is also usually the wrong thing to worry about.

Here is what the form actually asks, what it does not ask, and what gets found out regardless.

What the North Carolina form asks about claims

North Carolina sellers of most residential resales complete the Residential Property and Owners’ Association Disclosure Statement, required under Chapter 47E of the General Statutes and prescribed by rule 21 NCAC 58A .0114. You fill it out and give it to the buyer before the offer is made.

That rule sets out what the statement has to address. On flooding, the statement must cover whether any portion of the property is designated as within a special flood hazard area, whether it has a flood elevation certificate, whether it is insured for flood damage, whether it has experienced damage from natural events causing water seepage, and whether it “has had a claim filed for flood damage or received federal financial assistance for flood damage.” Those flood questions were added to the form effective July 1, 2024.

By the numbers

  • The disclosure statement must address whether the property “has had a claim filed for flood damage or received federal financial assistance for flood damage” 21 NCAC 58A .0114(a)(11), North Carolina Administrative Code, read November 20, 2026
  • The flood history and flood insurance questions took effect on the form on July 1, 2024 Coastal Review, “Flood history questions added to real estate disclosure form,” July 2024
  • A buyer who does not receive the disclosure statement before making an offer may cancel the contract within three calendar days of receiving it N.C.G.S. 47E-5(b), North Carolina General Assembly, read November 20, 2026
  • A CLUE report shows a property’s insurance claims for the past seven years and is compiled by LexisNexis from participating insurers Texas Department of Insurance consumer guidance and LexisNexis Risk Solutions, read November 20, 2026

Notice what is not there. The form does not ask you to list every homeowners claim you have ever filed. A hail claim on the roof in 2019, a kitchen pipe in 2022, a tree on the fence last spring: none of those has a dedicated question the way a flood claim now does.

Why that does not mean you should stay quiet

The form asks about condition as well as claims, and that is where most prior claims surface. If the claim was for roof damage, the roof question is still there. If it was for water intrusion, the questions about moisture, drainage and water seepage are still there. A claim is usually evidence that something happened to the house, and the thing that happened is what the buyer is entitled to know about.

Then there is the practical reality. When your buyer applies for homeowners insurance, the carrier pulls a CLUE report, which compiles claims filed on that address over the past seven years from participating insurers. Your buyer can order one too. So the sequence we watch play out is simple: you say nothing, the buyer’s insurance quote comes back loaded or declined, the buyer asks why, and now you are explaining a 2022 claim during due diligence rather than before the offer. That is the expensive version.

North Carolina also lets you answer “No Representation” to the questions on the form. It is a legitimate option and it is not the shield sellers think it is. Checking it down the entire page tends to make buyers order more inspections, not fewer, and it does not relieve you of liability for a willful misstatement elsewhere.

What we tell coastal sellers to do instead

Disclose the claim, and disclose the repair in the same breath. A roof that was replaced after a 2021 wind claim with a permitted, warrantied installation is a selling point, not a liability. A buyer who learns about the claim from you, with the invoice attached, reads it as a newer roof. A buyer who learns about it from an insurance underwriter reads it as a seller who hid something.

Pull your own claims history before you list so you are not guessing. Get the invoices and permits together for anything that was repaired. If the claim was flood related, have the elevation certificate ready as well, because your buyer’s lender and insurer will both want it. Our guide to coastal NC homeowners insurance explains how wind, hail and named storm deductibles are actually priced here, and our Wilmington flood zones guide covers the flood side.

When you are ready to put the house on the market, our listing services page explains how we prepare a file like this, and a free home value estimate will give you a starting number. For what is selling and how fast, see our Brunswick County market update.

Where this gets complicated

We will not pretend disclosure is free. A claims history can make a buyer’s insurance quote more expensive or harder to place, and on a coastal house that quote is sometimes what decides the deal. Two or three water claims in a short span is a genuinely difficult file, and the honest advice there is to get your own quotes before listing so you know what your buyer will face. There is also a real legal line we cannot draw for you. The disclosure act is a disclosure statute, not a warranty, and whether a particular omission creates liability is a question for a North Carolina real estate attorney, not for your broker. If a prior claim involved structural damage, mold remediation or a settlement with conditions attached, get legal advice before you fill out the form rather than after the buyer’s lawyer asks.

Related questions people also ask

Does a prior claim have to be disclosed if the damage was repaired?

The repair does not erase the condition question. If the form asks about the roof and the roof was damaged and replaced, the honest answer describes what happened and what was done about it. Most buyers react better to a documented repair than to a vague answer, because a completed repair with permits and a warranty removes uncertainty. Keep the paperwork and hand it over with the disclosure.

What is a CLUE report and can a buyer get one on my house?

A CLUE report is a claims history for an address, compiled by LexisNexis from insurers who report to it, covering roughly the last seven years. Insurance carriers pull it when they quote a policy. A property owner can request their own report, and buyers frequently ask sellers to provide one during due diligence on coastal homes. Assume the information will be visible to the people underwriting your buyer’s policy.

Can I just answer No Representation on the disclosure form?

You can, and it is a lawful choice on the North Carolina form. It is not a way to conceal something you know, and overusing it has a cost. Buyers reading a form with no answers on it tend to respond by ordering more inspections and by discounting their offer for the unknown. We generally advise answering what you actually know and using No Representation only where you genuinely have no knowledge.

Your next step

Before you list, request your own claims history for the address and gather the invoices, permits and warranties for anything that was repaired, then decide with your agent how to present it rather than whether to mention it. We handle coastal files like this across New Hanover, Brunswick and Pender counties and can tell you how a particular claim is likely to read to a buyer and an underwriter. Bring us the details and we will plan it with you.

Schedule a consultation

Matthew Kane, Tidal Realty Partners, Wilmington, NC. NC Broker #297432, Real Broker LLC (NC Firm #C34379). (910) 372-6720, info@tidalrealtypartners.com.

Sources: 21 NCAC 58A .0114, North Carolina Administrative Code, read November 20, 2026. N.C.G.S. 47E-4 and 47E-5, North Carolina General Assembly, read November 20, 2026. Coastal Review, “Flood history questions added to real estate disclosure form,” July 2024. Texas Department of Insurance consumer guidance on CLUE reports and LexisNexis Risk Solutions, read November 20, 2026. Tidal Realty Partners Brunswick County market update, Redfin county data, three months ending September 2026.

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message

Showing homes, neighborhoods and agents in