What Does It Cost to Own a Home on Caswell Beach, NC?

Caswell Beach homeowners pay a combined 53.2 cents per $100 in county and town property tax. The larger cost is insurance, and the island costs nobody budgets.
Aerial view of the Oak Island and Caswell Beach town line in Brunswick County, North Carolina, with the Oak Island street grid on the left and the oceanfront condominiums, townhomes and golf course of Caswell Beach on the right
The short answer

Plan on a combined county and town property tax rate of 53.2 cents per $100 of tax value on Caswell Beach, which is $3,192 a year on a home valued at $600,000, plus two insurance policies instead of one, plus whatever your specific community charges in dues. The part most buyers underestimate is not the tax bill. It is the insurance, and the fact that an oceanfront island carries costs that do not show up on any monthly statement until the year they do.

Caswell Beach is the quiet eastern end of Oak Island. One road runs through it, Caswell Beach Road, with the Oak Island Lighthouse about halfway down and Fort Caswell at the tip. There is no commercial strip and no stoplight. Southport is about nine miles and twenty minutes away by car, and downtown Wilmington is about thirty-three miles and fifty minutes (driving distances measured on OpenStreetMap routing, November 2026).

That isolation is most of the appeal, and it is also why the cost of ownership here looks different from a home in Leland or Ogden. You are paying to maintain a position on a barrier island. Our Caswell Beach community guide covers the place itself. This is the money.

What the tax bill actually looks like

Caswell Beach homeowners pay two ad valorem rates: the Brunswick County rate and the Town of Caswell Beach rate. For 2026 those are 34.20 cents and 19 cents per $100 of value, a combined 53.20 cents (Brunswick County Tax Office tax rates, 2026). That is a low combined rate by coastal standards. Southport’s town rate alone is 31 cents and Oak Island’s is 20 cents on the same county base (Brunswick County Tax Office tax rates, 2026).

By the numbers

  • Brunswick County rate: 34.20 cents per $100 of value Brunswick County Tax Office, 2026
  • Town of Caswell Beach rate: 19 cents per $100 Brunswick County Tax Office, 2026
  • Combined: 53.20 cents per $100, or $2,660 on a $500,000 tax value and $4,788 on a $900,000 tax value Brunswick County Tax Office, 2026, arithmetic ours

One caution we give every buyer: the bill is calculated on the county’s tax value, not on what you paid, and on an island where few homes trade those two numbers can sit a long way apart. Pull the parcel record from the Brunswick County tax site, read the tax value for that exact address, and do the arithmetic yourself. A future reappraisal can move it.

Two insurance policies, not one

Inland, most buyers carry a single homeowners policy. On Caswell Beach you should expect to assemble coverage from more than one place: a homeowners policy, wind and hail coverage that may be written separately or through the North Carolina Insurance Underwriting Association, and flood coverage, which no homeowners policy includes. That structure, not any single premium, is what drives the number.

The detail that surprises people is the deductible. Coastal wind policies here commonly set the named-storm deductible as a percentage of dwelling coverage rather than a flat dollar amount, so 2% on $800,000 of dwelling coverage is $16,000 out of pocket before the policy pays. We walk through that math, including the Beach Plan ceiling, in our guide to coastal North Carolina homeowners insurance, and the flood side in our Wilmington flood zones and flood insurance guide.

We will not give you an average premium for Caswell Beach, and you should be skeptical of anyone who does. There is no state or association publication that reports an average premium for this island, and the online estimators we checked disagreed with each other by a factor of five for the same ZIP code. The only number worth planning around is a real quote on the specific address, bound to that home’s elevation certificate, roof age and distance from the water. Get it during due diligence, not after.

HOA dues depend on which Caswell Beach you buy in

People talk about Caswell Beach as one place, but as a cost question it is several. Some homes on Caswell Beach Road belong to no association at all. Others sit inside gated communities with their own amenities, and the condominium and townhome regimes carry master insurance inside the dues, which is why their monthly number can look alarming next to a single-family home two streets away while covering more.

So the honest answer on dues is that there is no island-wide figure, and we will not invent one. What we can tell you is how to get the real number before your due diligence period ends. North Carolina’s standard contract, Offer to Purchase and Contract Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025, puts the cost of the resale certificate and of confirming the seller’s dues account on the seller, in paragraph 9(a), including any expedite fee the association charges for producing it. It puts a different set of charges on you as the buyer, in paragraph 9(b): working capital contributions, membership fees and move-in fees.

Ask for the budget, the last two years of minutes and the reserve study, not just the dues figure. On a barrier island, a thin reserve is a future special assessment with no date attached to it yet.

The island costs that are not on a monthly bill

Sand is the one nobody budgets for. Caswell Beach has been nourished before: the Program for the Study of Developed Shorelines at Western Carolina University records nourishment episodes here in 2001 and 2009, with the 2009 project costing $13.4 million in original dollars (Program for the Study of Developed Shorelines, Western Carolina University). The town maintains a dedicated beach renourishment fund separate from its general fund, which its own audited financial statements describe, and part of its occupancy tax is earmarked for beach nourishment and protection.

So a special assessment is a real line in your planning, not a scare story, and the contract handles the timing precisely. Paragraph 8(k) requires the seller to pay in full at settlement any special assessment approved before settlement, lump sum or installments, provided the amount can be reasonably determined. Paragraph 6(b) says you take title subject to all special assessments approved after settlement (Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025). Paragraph 4 lists investigation of assessments under consideration by a government or an association as a due diligence item. Use it.

One more item belongs in the budget. If you plan to rent the home, management fees, the occupancy tax and the wear a rental cycle puts on a coastal exterior change the arithmetic again. Our guide to buying a beach house near Wilmington walks through the rental side.

Where this gets complicated

We could not verify the Town of Caswell Beach’s current fee schedule or its adopted FY 2026-27 budget from a published document today, so we are not publishing a trash, stormwater or town utility figure for you to plan around. Call Town Hall and ask for the current fee schedule. The second complication is price: Caswell Beach is a very thin market, often only a handful of recorded sales in a month, so any “median price for Caswell Beach” you read swings hundreds of thousands of dollars from one quarter to the next and is not a budget. Use the comps for the specific street and the specific side of Caswell Beach Road instead. The wider county picture is on our Brunswick County market update, where the median was $394,000 with homes taking 93 days to sell as of our October 2026 update, and understand that an oceanfront island on the county’s eastern edge does not behave like that median at all.

Related questions people also ask

Is Caswell Beach cheaper to own than Oak Island?

On the property tax line, the two are close: Caswell Beach’s 2026 town rate is 19 cents per $100 of value and Oak Island’s is 20 cents, on the same Brunswick County rate of 34.20 cents, according to the Brunswick County Tax Office. The ownership cost difference usually comes from elsewhere, mainly insurance on a given structure and whether the home sits in an association with dues. Caswell Beach also has far fewer homes and no commercial district, so services and amenities you might walk to on Oak Island are a drive away. Cheaper on paper does not always mean cheaper to live in.

Do I need flood insurance on Caswell Beach?

If you are financing the home and it sits in a FEMA special flood hazard area, your lender will require flood insurance, and a standard homeowners policy never covers flood damage regardless of what a lender requires. Even where it is not required, we tell buyers on a barrier island to carry it, because the cost of being wrong once is a rebuild. Check the specific address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and ask the seller for an elevation certificate during due diligence, since elevation drives both the requirement and the premium. Two homes on the same street can land in different zones.

How far is Caswell Beach from a hospital and an airport?

Dosher Memorial Hospital in Southport is the closest, about nine miles and roughly twenty minutes from the middle of Caswell Beach Road, with Novant Health Brunswick Medical Center in Bolivia the larger campus further inland. Wilmington International Airport is about thirty-nine miles and a little over an hour by car, measured on OpenStreetMap routing in November 2026. For many retirees that drive time is the deciding factor, so we suggest driving it once at the time of day you would actually drive it before you commit.

Your next step

Before you make an offer on Caswell Beach, build the real annual number for the specific address: pull the parcel tax value from the Brunswick County site and apply the 53.20-cent combined rate, get a bound insurance quote with the named-storm deductible spelled out, and ask the association for its budget and reserve study. If you want a second set of eyes on those three documents, send them to our team and we will read them with you before your due diligence period runs out.

Schedule a consultation

Matthew Kane, Tidal Realty Partners, Wilmington, NC. NC Broker #297432, Real Broker LLC (NC Firm #C34379). (910) 372-6720, info@tidalrealtypartners.com.

Sources: Brunswick County Tax Office, Tax Rates (2024, 2025 and 2026 columns), accessed November 2026. North Carolina Offer to Purchase and Contract, Standard Form 2-T, revised 7/2025, paragraphs 4, 6(b), 8(k), 9(a), 9(b) and 10(d). Program for the Study of Developed Shorelines, Western Carolina University, beach nourishment database entry for Caswell Beach (episodes 2001 and 2009; 2009 cost $13.4 million in original dollars). Town of Caswell Beach audited financial statements, beach renourishment special revenue fund. North Carolina Restaurant and Lodging Association, Profile of North Carolina Occupancy Taxes and Their Investment, July 2026 (Caswell Beach nourishment earmark). Tidal Realty Partners Brunswick County market update, October 2026. Driving distances measured on OpenStreetMap routing, November 2026.

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message

Showing homes, neighborhoods and agents in