Yes, but you have to bring the difference to closing or get your lender to accept less than it is owed, which is a short sale. The lender has to release its lien before the deed can transfer, so the question is never whether you can sell, it is who covers the gap.
Most Wilmington owners asking this are not as far underwater as they fear. The gap is usually not the loan balance against the value. It is the loan balance plus the cost of selling against the value, and that second number catches people out.
So before anything else, let us be specific about what you are actually subtracting.
What “underwater” really costs in Wilmington
Figure your net, not your price. On a North Carolina sale the seller pays the excise tax on the deed, $1.00 for each $500 or fraction of the sale price under state statute, so a $400,000 sale carries $800. Then there are commissions, the closing attorney, prorated taxes, any negotiated repairs or buyer closing cost credit, and the payoff itself, which includes interest to the day of closing rather than your statement balance.
Add those up and a house that appears to have a little equity can close with nothing left. That is the most common version of this problem we see, and it is also the most fixable, because several of those costs are negotiable and one of them, the repair credit, is decided by how well the house is prepared.
- New Hanover County median sale price: $464,000 for the three months ending September 2026, down 1.3 percent year over year Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update
- Typical time to go under contract: 61 days, against 34 a year earlier, and two of every five active listings have already taken a price cut Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update, September 2026 data
- North Carolina excise tax paid by the seller: $1.00 per $500 or fraction of the sale price NC General Statutes 105-228.30
- 30-year fixed mortgage rate: 7.18 percent for the week ending November 5, 2026 Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey via FRED
Who is actually underwater here, and who only thinks they are
Values in New Hanover County have softened rather than fallen. The median sale price was $464,000 for the three months ending September 2026, down 1.3 percent year over year, according to our New Hanover County market update. A 1.3 percent move does not put long-time owners underwater.
Who it does reach is a narrow group: owners who bought in the last two or three years with a small down payment, owners who refinanced and took cash out near the top, owners carrying a second lien or a HELOC on top of the first, and owners of new construction who paid for a rate buydown and options that did not add resale value. If you are in that group, the number to get is not a guess. Start with a real payoff quote from your servicer, good through a specific date, and a realistic price based on what has actually closed near you.
Our home value estimate is where that conversation starts, but an automated figure is not what you should make this decision on. For a house where the equity question is this close, we would rather put eyes on it.
Your four realistic options
Bring cash to closing. If the gap is a few thousand dollars and you need to move, this is the simplest path and it keeps your credit untouched.
Wait, and rent it out in the meantime. The calendar is slower than it was, with 61 days on market against 34 a year earlier, but prices in the county have held within about a percent of last year. If you do not have to sell this quarter, time is often the cheapest solution to a small gap.
Sell with a short sale. Your lender agrees to release its lien for less than the balance. It takes lender approval, it takes longer than a normal sale, and it affects your credit.
Take a cash offer at a discount to close fast. Sometimes a lower certain number beats a higher uncertain one, particularly if you are relocating on a date you do not control. Our cash offer path exists for exactly that trade, and we will tell you plainly when it is the wrong one.
The tax rule that changed, and most people have not heard
This is the part we most want you to know before you start a short sale. When a lender forgives part of a mortgage balance, the forgiven amount is generally taxable income, and the lender may report it to you on Form 1099-C.
There used to be a reliable exclusion for this on a main home, called qualified principal residence indebtedness. The IRS’s current guidance on canceled debt, last updated September 24, 2026, states that the exclusion applies to debt discharged before January 1, 2026, or discharged under an arrangement entered into and evidenced in writing before January 1, 2026. A short sale negotiated and closed today does not meet either condition.
Other exclusions may still apply, including insolvency, and the arithmetic depends entirely on your whole financial picture. We are not accountants and this is not tax advice. We raise it because we have watched sellers choose a short sale to avoid writing a check at closing, and then meet a tax bill in April that was larger than the check would have been. Talk to a CPA before you accept a short sale, not after.
A short sale is not one negotiation, it is as many as you have liens. A second mortgage or a HELOC holder has to agree separately, and a junior lienholder with little to gain has little reason to cooperate quickly. HOA assessments, judgments and tax liens all have to clear too. And the lender’s approval is not a promise about the deficiency: whether you still owe the shortfall afterward depends on what the approval letter says, which is why that letter should be read by a North Carolina real estate attorney before you sign it rather than celebrated as the finish line.
Related questions people also ask
Will a short sale hurt my credit?
Yes, though generally less than a foreclosure. A short sale is reported as a debt settled for less than the full amount owed, which lowers a credit score and stays on the report for years, and any late payments made along the way are reported separately. How much it costs you depends on where your score started and how the servicer codes the account, so ask the lender in writing how they will report it before you agree to anything.
How long does a short sale take in North Carolina?
Longer than a conventional sale, and the timeline belongs to the lender rather than to you or your buyer. The lender has to order its own valuation, review a hardship package and approve the final settlement statement, and each of those steps can stall. Buyers who need to close on a schedule often lose patience, so a short sale listing should be marketed honestly as a short sale from the first day rather than revealed later.
Can I just give the house back to the lender instead?
That is a deed in lieu of foreclosure, and some lenders will consider it, usually only after a genuine attempt to sell has failed. It is simpler than a short sale because there is no buyer to keep happy, but it has similar credit consequences and the same unanswered question about whether any remaining balance is forgiven or pursued. It is worth asking a real estate attorney to compare it against a short sale for your specific loan before you choose.
Get two documents before you decide anything: a written payoff quote from your servicer, good through a date, and a realistic net sheet for your house at a price the current market will actually pay. Send us the address and the payoff figure and we will build the second one for you, including what the house would net if you sold it in sixty days and what it would net if you waited six months. These conversations are private and we are glad to have one with you.
Sources: Internal Revenue Service, Topic No. 431, Canceled Debt, last updated September 24, 2026; North Carolina General Statutes 105-228.30, excise tax on conveyances; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week ending November 5, 2026, via FRED; Tidal Realty Partners New Hanover County market update, three months ending September 2026.



