Neighborhood Guides

Silver Lake, NC

Your guide to Silver Lake, two and a half square miles of unincorporated New Hanover County between Carolina Beach Road and River Road, south of Wilmington.

17
Active Listings
$299K–$1.3M
Active Home Price Range
$464,000
County Median Sale Price
.3785
Tax Rate per $100
Listings and range: Coldwell Banker Silver Lake page, read November 12, 2026: 26 listings, 17 active and 9 pending, 16 active houses and townhomes from $299,000 to $1,299,000 plus one vacant lot at $250,000. County median: our New Hanover County market update, three months ending September 2026. Tax rate: New Hanover County historic tax rates, 2026, county .3020 plus debt service .0040 plus fire district .0725 per $100; Silver Lake is unincorporated, so there is no municipal rate. Photos: USDA National Agriculture Imagery Program orthoimagery via USGS, The National Map, acquired September 23, 2022, public domain.

Neighborhood Overview: Silver Lake homes for sale

Silver Lake is a census designated place in southern New Hanover County, 2.47 square miles of residential streets between Carolina Beach Road and River Road by the Census Bureau’s measure. It takes its name from the long narrow lake at its center, ringed on every side by private back yards. No town hall, no main street, no gate.

Every address is Wilmington 28412: we checked all 2,479 improved residential parcels against the county GIS ZIP layer on November 12, 2026 and every one fell in that ZIP. And none of it is in the city. Every parcel carries a municipality code of FD on the county’s 2026 tax roll, county fire district rather than Wilmington, worth about a third of a percent a year on your tax bill.

The 2020-2024 American Community Survey counts 6,563 people, plus or minus 1,043, in 2,818 housing units: 2,355 single family detached and 266 mobile homes. Of 2,740 occupied units, 2,252 are owner occupied, about 82 percent, and the median house was built in 1996.

The county subdivision layer shows more than twenty recorded plats inside the boundary, roughly 2,300 lots. The older conventional side is Arrowhead with 343, Marquis Hills with 276, Brewster Place with 219, Silva Terra with 212 and Silver Lake itself with 103. The newer side is the Village at Motts Landing with 364 in two sections. North and east is Monkey Junction. West across River Road is RiverLights.

Home Price Ranges

On November 12, 2026 the Coldwell Banker Silver Lake page carried 26 listings, 17 active and 9 pending. Sixteen are houses or townhomes and one is a vacant lot at $250,000. The sixteen homes run $299,000 to $1,299,000, median asking $551,950, median 49 days on market.

Asking prices are not sale prices. The county tax roll records 107 residential sales of $10,000 or more inside the boundary in the twelve months to November 12, 2026, median $350,000, range $130,000 to $928,000. The 2026 county appraisal across the 2,479 improved residential parcels has a median of $338,200. The 2020-2024 American Community Survey median owner-occupied value is $325,500, plus or minus $46,947.

Our New Hanover County market update puts the county median sale price at $464,000 for the three months ending September 2026, down 1.3 percent year over year, with 61 days on market against 34 a year ago. Silver Lake trades under that because of the housing stock, not the location. The median improved house here has 1,578 heated square feet on 0.29 acres.

The top of the market is new construction on Ellen Dale Place and the larger houses around Motts Forest Road, asking $900,000 and up. The bottom is the small 1970s houses off Horn Road and Normandy Drive, still under $370,000 this month. Both are Silver Lake, four minutes apart.

Lifestyle & Community

What is here, and what is a short drive:

  • Arrowhead Park, 720 Arnold Road: the county park inside the neighborhood, with two tennis courts, a basketball court, a multi-purpose field, a playground, a gaga ball pit and a picnic shelter on the county parks feature layer.
  • Silver Lake itself: lined with private lots and docks, with no public access point in the county parks layer. To get the water you buy a house on it.
  • River Road Park, 2 miles southwest: a county park on the Cape Fear River with a public pier.
  • Marina Village at RiverLights, 3.8 miles and 9 minutes: the nearest walkable cluster of restaurants and shops.
  • Monkey Junction, 1.6 miles and 4 minutes: groceries, pharmacies and restaurants.
  • Cameron Art Museum, 3201 South 17th Street, 2.9 miles north.

The honest version is that Silver Lake has no town center and nothing to walk to. The commercial frontage runs from about 4550 to 5302 Carolina Beach Road, and on the 2026 tax roll it is mostly self storage, an auto parts store, an ABC store and a lodge hall. Most interior streets have no sidewalks. What you get in exchange is quiet.

Schools & Education

Silver Lake is served by New Hanover County Schools, and the elementary line runs through it. Sampling the district’s attendance boundary layer, the one behind the official NHCS school locator, at 540 points on November 12, 2026: 64 percent are zoned to Mary C. Williams Elementary and 36 percent to Heyward C. Bellamy Elementary. Every point goes to Myrtle Grove Middle, and 537 of 540 to Eugene Ashley High. The figures below are NC DPI 2025-26 results.

  • Mary C. Williams Elementary, 801 Silver Lake Road, K-5, capacity 461, inside the neighborhood. Growth Met, 53.5 percent grade level proficient, 31.7 percent college and career ready.
  • Heyward C. Bellamy Elementary, 70 Sanders Road, K-5, capacity 543. Growth Exceeded, 79.8 percent proficient, 61.4 percent college and career ready.
  • Myrtle Grove Middle School, 901 Piner Road, 6-8, capacity 674. Growth Not Met, 63.3 percent proficient, 43.9 percent college and career ready.
  • Eugene Ashley High School, 555 Halyburton Memorial Parkway, 9-12. Growth Not Met, 62.2 percent proficient, 40.2 percent college and career ready.

None of the four is on NC DPI’s 2025-26 Low-Performing State Designations list, which names five New Hanover County schools. The two elementary schools are not interchangeable: Bellamy’s proficiency runs 26 points ahead of Williams. Confirm the assignment for a specific address, because the boundary does not follow the subdivision lines.

Getting Around

Carolina Beach Road, US 421, is the eastern edge and the way most people leave. River Road is the quieter western edge, and Sanders Road crosses between them.

Approximate free-flow driving distances and times from the center of the place, routed over OpenStreetMap on November 12, 2026: Monkey Junction 1.6 miles and 4 minutes, Marina Village at RiverLights 3.8 and 9, Novant NHRMC 5.5 and 12, downtown Wilmington 7.3 and 15, UNCW 7.9 and 17, the Carolina Beach boardwalk 9.1 and 16, Wrightsville Beach 11.9 and 24, the airport 13.4 and 28. None includes traffic.

And there is traffic. NCDOT’s 2025 annual average daily counts put US 421 just south of Sanders Road at 47,500 vehicles a day, up from 46,500 in 2023. Sanders Road west of the highway carries 11,000.

What Buyers Should Know

Flooding is the good news. We ran all 2,479 improved residential parcels against the New Hanover County FloodHazards_2025 layer on November 12, 2026. Of those, 2,245 sit in Zone X, minimal hazard. Ninety nine are Zone AE and two are AE floodway, so 101 parcels, 4.1 percent, are in the special flood hazard area where a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance. Another 133 sit in the 0.2 percent band, and there is no Zone V anywhere here. The AE parcels cluster along Motts Creek, so pull the determination for the address you want.

Insurance still costs coastal money. ZIP 28412 is in Territory 140, Eastern Coastal, on the North Carolina Department of Insurance 2024 homeowners settlement table published January 17, 2025. The Rate Bureau asked 71.4 percent there; the approved increases were 10.5 percent in 2025 and 10.1 in 2026. Nine miles inland does not exempt you from percentage-based wind and hail deductibles. Get a real quote during due diligence.

Your tax bill is the county rate only. On New Hanover County’s published 2026 rates the county levies .3020 per $100, plus .0040 debt service and .0725 for the unincorporated fire service district, a total of .3785. On the median improved appraisal of $338,200 that is about $1,280 a year, before the stormwater fee. The same house inside the city would add Wilmington’s .3315.

HOA structure depends on the plat. The 2026 tax roll shows 60 homeowner association parcels inside the boundary, all in newer performance subdivisions: the Village at Motts Landing, Glenn Ellen, Bellamy Parke, Yorke Meadow, Sycamore Grove and Austin Commons. Older plats such as Arrowhead, Marquis Hills and Silva Terra carry no HOA common area at all. Ask for the covenants and the dues.

Confirm water and sewer. The Cape Fear Public Utility Authority serves Wilmington, Wrightsville Beach and much of unincorporated New Hanover County, but the county publishes no open layer of connections, and older lots here can still be on a well or septic.

The highway out front is scheduled to be rebuilt. NCDOT’s 2026-2035 State Transportation Improvement Program includes U-5790, a $54.5 million widening of US 421 from College Road to Sanders Road with flyovers at the NC 132 junction, right of way in 2027 and construction in 2029. That is the full length of Silver Lake’s eastern frontage. The finished road will be better. The years in between will not.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Silver Lake a good place to live?
It suits buyers who want space and quiet within fifteen minutes of downtown Wilmington and will drive for everything else. Lots run a median 0.29 acres on the 2026 county tax roll, 82 percent of occupied units are owner occupied per the 2020-2024 American Community Survey, and there is a county park inside the neighborhood. The trade-offs: no sidewalks, and a highway carrying 47,500 vehicles a day per NCDOT’s 2025 counts.
What do homes cost in Silver Lake?
On November 12, 2026 the Coldwell Banker Silver Lake page showed 16 active houses and townhomes from $299,000 to $1,299,000, median asking $551,950. Sales run lower: the county tax roll records 107 residential sales of $10,000 or more in the twelve months to that date, with a median of $350,000.
What schools serve Silver Lake?
Elementary is split. Sampling the New Hanover County Schools boundary layer at 540 points on November 12, 2026, 64 percent of the area is zoned to Mary C. Williams Elementary and 36 percent to Heyward C. Bellamy Elementary. Middle is Myrtle Grove Middle and high is Eugene Ashley High. None of the four is on NC DPI’s 2025-26 Low-Performing list.
How far is Silver Lake from downtown Wilmington and the beach?
About 7.3 miles and 15 minutes to downtown Wilmington and 9.1 miles and 16 minutes to the Carolina Beach boardwalk, routed free-flow over OpenStreetMap on November 12, 2026. Wrightsville Beach is about 11.9 miles and 24 minutes. Neither includes traffic.
What should I know about flooding and insurance in Silver Lake?
Of 2,479 improved residential parcels checked against the New Hanover County FloodHazards_2025 layer on November 12, 2026, 2,245 are Zone X with minimal hazard, 101 are in the special flood hazard area and 133 are in the 0.2 percent band. There is no Zone V. Insurance is separate: ZIP 28412 is in Territory 140, Eastern Coastal, on the NC Department of Insurance 2024 settlement table, with approved increases of 10.5 percent in 2025 and 10.1 in 2026.

Ready to Explore Silver Lake?

Silver Lake rewards buyers who want a big lot and an older house close to the city. We can pull the flood determination, the elementary assignment and the HOA status for any address here before you make an offer.

Schedule Consultation

Local Resources

Showing homes, neighborhoods and agents in