Neighborhood Guides

Bayshore, NC

An unincorporated Wilmington neighborhood of 623 lots on Pages Creek, with no city tax, no gate, no club, and docks straight out to the Intracoastal Waterway.

24
Listings On The Market
$97.5K–$2.7M
List Price Range
$464,000
County Median Sale Price
0.3785
Tax Rate per $100
Listings and range: Coldwell Banker, Bayshore NC, all pages read November 2, 2026; 24 unique MLS records, 16 active and 8 under contract, a $97,500 lot to a $2,700,000 house. County median: our New Hanover County market update, three months ending September 2026. Tax rate: New Hanover County Historic Tax Rates and the adopted FY 2026-27 budget, county 30.6 cents plus the 7.25-cent unincorporated fire service district rate, read November 2, 2026. Photos: NC Orthoimagery Program via NC OneMap, flown February 2024.

Neighborhood Overview: Bayshore homes for sale

Bayshore is a neighborhood, not a town. It sits east of Market Street in northern New Hanover County, between the highway and Pages Creek, with a Wilmington mailing address and the 28411 ZIP code. The county’s municipal boundary layer, queried November 2, 2026, returns one word for every address in it: unincorporated. No mayor, no town council, no city property tax.

The Census Bureau recognizes the place as Bayshore CDP, about 2.4 square miles of land with a 2020-2024 five-year population estimate of 2,949. Inside it, the county’s subdivision layer records one dominant plat: Bayshore Estates, 623 lots, recorded, conventional. Conventional is the county’s term for a standard lot-and-block layout rather than the clustered design of newer communities, and that is how it reads from the air. Straight streets, deep lots, mature trees, then the marsh. Zoning is R-15, the county’s 15,000 square foot residential district, which is why the lots feel generous here.

Read Bayshore as three markets in one neighborhood: older houses on dry interior lots, rebuilt and new homes on the creek with private docks, and raw lots in between. The ACS puts the median year built at 2001, a number that hides 1970s ranches, 1990s two-stories and new construction going up now. Of the 1,321 occupied housing units, 1,108 are owner-occupied, about 84 percent, and it shows in how little comes on the market at once.

Home Price Ranges

We read every page of the Coldwell Banker Bayshore results on November 2, 2026. After removing duplicates, 24 distinct listings were on the board, 16 active and 8 under contract. Eleven were houses or multi-family, 13 were land. The houses ran from $439,900 for a three-bedroom on Lilly Pond Drive, already under contract, to $2,700,000 for a four-bedroom of 3,690 square feet on Elmhurst Road. The cheapest of the five active houses was $499,000 for 1,687 square feet on Sanderling Place. New four-bedroom homes on Vale Drive asked $1,125,000 to $1,272,032.

The land is the part that surprises people. Thirteen lots and tracts were listed at once, from $97,500 for a third of an acre on Alexander Place to $1,900,000 for 17.84 acres on Plantation Road. That is a lot of dirt for a built neighborhood, and the clearest signal that Bayshore is still filling in.

The ACS puts the median home value in Bayshore CDP at $525,800, plus or minus $59,502, though that is self-reported owner estimates rather than sale prices. Our New Hanover County market update for the three months ending September 2026 puts the county median sale price at $464,000, down 1.3 percent year over year, with 61 days on market against 34 a year ago. Bayshore is not immune to that calendar. Two active listings had been out more than 90 days.

Lifestyle & Community

Bayshore has no commercial core. Everything is on the water behind the houses or on Market Street in front.

  • Pages Creek – the tidal creek along the eastern edge, with private piers running out across the marsh to the Intracoastal Waterway
  • Ogden Park – the county park at 615 Ogden Park Drive, with nine lighted tennis courts, three lighted soccer and football fields, a 10,000 square foot skatepark, a dog park and a one-mile accessible trail around the pond
  • Italian Bistro – at 8211 Market Street, hand-tossed pizza and Italian-American plates a few minutes up the road
  • Mayfaire Town Center – open-air shopping, dining and a cinema about six miles south
  • Wrightsville Beach – the nearest ocean beach, about eight miles southeast, with public access and town recreation programs

People buy here for the water and the quiet. If you want a clubhouse and a gate, look at Porters Neck.

Schools & Education

Bayshore is in New Hanover County Schools. Three addresses on Elmhurst Road, Graystone Road and Vale Drive, run through the district’s School Locator on November 2, 2026, returned the same assignment:

  • Porters Neck Elementary School – 416 Edgewater Club Road. Grade B, score 75 on the 2024-25 North Carolina School Report Cards, met expected growth
  • Holly Shelter Middle School – 3921 Roger Haynes Drive, Castle Hayne. Grade C, score 61, met expected growth
  • Emsley A. Laney High School – 2700 N. College Road. Grade C, score 62, did not meet expected growth

That middle and high school pairing is the honest weak spot here. Do not assume the schools match the price of the waterfront houses. Attendance lines have moved before, so confirm the assignment for the exact address before you write an offer.

Getting Around

Bayshore runs off Market Street, US 17 Business, the only road most residents use daily. Approximate routing estimates we computed on November 2, 2026 in free-flowing traffic put Porters Neck Center about 4 miles and 9 minutes north, Mayfaire about 6 miles and 14 minutes south, Wrightsville Beach about 8 miles and 16 minutes, and downtown Wilmington, the airport and the Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center main campus each about 10 miles out.

Those are free-flow numbers. Market Street at 5 pm is not, and we will not pretend otherwise. The stretch to Mayfaire is one signalized commercial driveway after another, and that afternoon backup is the complaint we hear most. Two road projects change the math. The Military Cutoff Road Extension opened September 28, 2023, more than four miles from Market Street to I-140 at a reported cost above $95 million. NCDOT awarded the final segment of the US 17 Hampstead Bypass in August 2025 for $182 million, about seven miles from N.C. 140 to N.C. 210, completing the nearly 13-mile bypass and expected to finish in 2030. When it opens, through traffic headed to Hampstead and Topsail should leave Market Street, and that is the biggest upside to Bayshore’s daily drive in the next five years.

What Buyers Should Know

Flood zones split this neighborhood in two. We queried FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer and New Hanover County’s 2025 flood hazard layer on November 2, 2026. Most of the interior is Zone X, outside the special flood hazard area, including Elmhurst Road and Graystone Road. Along Pages Creek the maps turn to AE with base flood elevations of 13 and 14 feet, a VE zone at 16 feet on the open water, and a 0.2 percent annual chance band between. Vale Drive, where the newest and priciest houses are, returned AE at 13 feet. The governing FIRM panel took effect April 3, 2006, old enough that we would not rely on it alone. Get a current elevation certificate.

Insurance is the number that moves the payment. Zone X removes the federal flood insurance requirement, not the coastal wind exposure. Policies here generally carry a separate named-storm or wind and hail deductible set as a percentage of insured value rather than a flat figure, and on a $700,000 house that is real money. Price it during due diligence.

Water and sewer are a live project, not a settled fact. Cape Fear Public Utility Authority sewer mains serve the neighborhood, and CFPUA smoke-tested the lines on Bayshore Drive, Shore Point Drive, Lost Tree Road, Aquarius Drive and Vale Drive from April 7 to 10, 2026 looking for breaks. Water is the open question. CFPUA’s Bayshore Water Main Interconnections project, listed at $12 million with an October 2025 start and a December 2027 completion, is running 16-inch and 12-inch mains through the area to connect the Richardson Water Treatment Plant to the Porters Neck Elevated Tanks. CFPUA has said the broader program is meant to reach properties still on private wells, some of which have tested positive for PFAS. Ask whether the house is on public water or a well, and if it is a well, ask for the test results.

There is no master association and no club. Bayshore Estates is a conventional recorded subdivision, not a gated community with a pool and dues. That keeps carrying costs low, and it means nobody maintains a shared amenity for you. Covenants and any dues run with the recorded plat for each section, so read the restrictions for the exact lot. Dock rights, pier easements and water access vary street to street.

Growth is coming up Market Street. Thirteen lots for sale inside a built neighborhood is not a quiet signal. Expect infill construction next to older houses for years, and more commercial space on Market Street. Short-term rental operators owe the New Hanover County room occupancy tax. Next door: Ogden, Porters Neck, Figure Eight Island across the water, and Wrightsville Beach.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bayshore a good place to live?
Bayshore suits a buyer who wants water access, a large lot and no city tax, within ten minutes of Porters Neck and twenty of downtown Wilmington. Eighty-four percent of its occupied homes are owner-occupied, which tells you people stay. The trade-offs are Market Street traffic, a middle school and a high school that both scored a C in 2024-25, no shared amenities, and infill construction still going.
What do homes cost in Bayshore?
On November 2, 2026 the Coldwell Banker Bayshore pages carried 24 unique listings, 16 active and 8 under contract. Houses ran $439,900 to $2,700,000, the cheapest active one $499,000. Thirteen of the 24 were land, from $97,500 for a third of an acre to $1,900,000 for a 17.84-acre tract.
What schools serve Bayshore?
Three Bayshore addresses run through the New Hanover County Schools School Locator on November 2, 2026 all returned Porters Neck Elementary, Holly Shelter Middle and Emsley A. Laney High. On the 2024-25 North Carolina School Report Cards, Porters Neck Elementary earned a B and met growth, Holly Shelter a C and met growth, and Laney a C and did not meet growth. Confirm the assignment for your address before you write an offer.
How far is Bayshore from downtown Wilmington and the beach?
Approximate routing estimates computed November 2, 2026 in free-flowing traffic put downtown Wilmington about 10 miles and 19 minutes away, Wrightsville Beach about 8 miles and 16 minutes, and Porters Neck Center about 4 miles and 9 minutes. Add time in the afternoon, because Market Street is the only practical route.
What should I know about flooding and insurance in Bayshore?
It depends which street you are on. In our November 2, 2026 queries of FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer and New Hanover County’s 2025 flood layer, Elmhurst Road and Graystone Road returned Zone X, outside the special flood hazard area, while Vale Drive returned Zone AE at a base flood elevation of 13 feet and the open water edge is mapped VE at 16 feet. The governing FIRM panel took effect April 3, 2006, so get a current elevation certificate. Zone X removes the federal flood insurance requirement, but wind and hail deductibles here are usually a percentage of insured value.

Ready to Explore Bayshore?

We will tell you which Bayshore streets are in Zone X, what the dock and water rights actually say on a given lot, and whether a house is on CFPUA water or a well.

Schedule Consultation

Local Resources

Showing homes, neighborhoods and agents in